By aaron j biterman september 11, 2000 democracy is a system of majority rule, which excludes the opinions of those not in the majority, and for that reason i agree with the thesis of the ancient philosopher plato he believed that because the desires and possessions of some inevitably interfere with the desires and. In terms of the evolution of one system of government from another, plato's point is that tyranny, though ostensibly initiated as a reaction against the chaos of democracy, is in fact an extension of it tyranny embodies the utmost depths of anarchy and lawlessness hence the degeneration from aristocracy. [tags: plato], 911 words (26 pages), strong essays, [preview] · plato's criticism of democracy - plato's criticism of democracy do not be angry with me for speaking the truth no man will survive who genuinely opposes you or any other crowd and prevents the occurrence of many unjust and illegal happenings in the city. [δ]έκϰα κϰτλ (delos, iii bc) 8 j barnes, “aristotle and political liberty,” in r kraut and s skultety (eds), aristotle's politics critical essays (lanham 2005) 185–201, at 190 9 [xen] athpol 112 xen hell 738 at pl lach 186b foreigners (ξένoι) are opposed to citizens (ἀθηναῖoι) and subdivided into slaves (δoῦλoι. Democracy is thus highly corruptible it opens gates to demagogues, potential dictators, and can thus lead to tyranny hence, although it may not be applicable to modern liberal democracies, plato's main charge against the democracy he knows from the ancient greek political practice is that it is unstable, leading from.
The republic study guide contains a biography of plato, literature essays, a complete e-text, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full therefore, socrates tells his auditors, the insatiable desire for freedom evolves democracy into tyranny plato's critique of democracy is highly ironic at first. Democracy may be criticized as: economically inefficient, politically unrealistic, dysfunctional, morally corrupt or sociopolitically suboptimal important figures associated with anti-democratic thought include martin heidegger, hubert lagardelle, charles maurras, friedrich nietzsche, adolf hitler, plato, aristotle, carl schmitt,. Fewer than a quarter know who their senators are, and only half are aware that their state has two of them democracy is other people, and the ignorance of the many has long galled the few, especially the few who consider themselves intellectuals plato, one of the earliest to see democracy as a problem,. Now (in book viii) socrates returns to his examples of unjust societies and unjust men socrates argues that there are four main types of unjust states: timocracy, oligarchy (plutocracy), democracy, and tyranny (despotism) socrates says that timocracy is the closest to the ideal state that we have thus far experienced the.
However, examining the terms of plato's objections reveals that his attack is not of democracy as the political manifestation of freedom and equality that it represents in modern times, but on the moral indolence he sees in society while plato is generally applauded for his criticism of this (for it should be criticised) what he. For plato, majority rules system was the most exceedingly bad of all legitimate governments and the best of all untamed ones (the republic plato) aristotle's main criticism of democracy was that there was no one type of democracy, rather they were multiple the reason behind these multiple democracies.
Free essay: so democracy is a system of government wherein the people elect their rulers in the case of athens, it was, more or less, a direct democracy. Take note that there might be some consideration as to whether or not, particularly with regard to the socratic dialogues, the criticism of democracy's properties originated from socrates or plato but with regards to this essay, such a consideration is irrelevant, as it is not incorrect to say that plato did indeed. Plato thought that any democracy would be overrun by the 'tyranny of the majority ' (this is why modern democracies have constitutions) in contrast to this, he proposed a form of 'enlightened' despotism where people are put into ranked castes, wit.
Plato's republic vs democracy ogochukwu okpala introduction in this era when individuals are questioning the legitimacy and wisdom of unregulated free freedom to criticize government, to publish their criticism and to present alternatives” (what is democracy, 2008) in a democracy, after the candidates have. The following essay was written as part of the athens to alexander unit at dickson college, semester 2, 2011 it responds to the self-devised focus question: 'how does plato criticise athenian democracy in the republic' tom hermes has also contributed minoan religion and the ancient greeks to clio.
Many modern democratic theorists consider athens in its golden age to be a model of democratic practice plato, however, is highly critical of his society's form of government how does the republic criticize athenian democracy is plato's critique valid outline i thesis statement: despite the modern praise of athens for. 212 instrumental arguments against democracy not all instrumental arguments favor democracy plato (republic, book vi) argues that democracy is inferior to various forms of monarchy, aristocracy and even oligarchy on the grounds that democracy tends to undermine the expertise necessary to.